Alternatives in Jewish Bioethics by Noam J. Zohar

By Noam J. Zohar

This discussion among the Jewish normative culture and Western ethical philosophy addresses imperative modern concerns in clinical ethics.

Alternatives in Jewish Bioethics involves a discussion among modern, Western ethical philosophy and the Jewish culture of legal/moral discourse (Halakha). spotting that no unmarried culture has a monopoly on legitimate ethical teachings, it seeks to counterpoint our moral views via mutual alternate.

This is facilitated through a non-authoritarian method of Judaism--a transparent replacement to the implicitly insular, "take-it-or-leave-it" strategy usually encountered during this box. Following within the footsteps of classical rabbinic discussions, normative pronouncements are grounded in purposes, open to severe exam. The "alternatives" are in the ebook as well--the presentation all through avoids one-sided conclusions, bringing up and examining or extra positions to make feel of the controversy. those specific arguments also are associated with a bigger photo, contrasting easy topics: spiritual naturalism as opposed to non secular humanism.

Concretely, the publication addresses a few of the relevant modern concerns within the ethics of medication. those comprise assisted suicide and euthanasia, donor insemination and "surrogate" motherhood, using human cadavers for studying and examine, and allocation of scarce assets at either the person and social degrees.

Show description

Read Online or Download Alternatives in Jewish Bioethics PDF

Best jewish books

Music and the Play of Power in the Middle East, North Africa and Central Asia

What's it concerning the background, geographical place and cultures of the center East, North Africa and significant Asia that has made track this type of powerful and strong agent? This quantity offers the 1st direct examine the complicated courting among song and tool throughout various musical genres and international locations.

Encyclopaedia Judaica Volume 22 (Thematic Outline & Index)

Encyclopaedia Judaica, quantity 22: Thematic define and Index
Encyclopaedia Judaica, quantity 22: Thematic define and Index

Additional info for Alternatives in Jewish Bioethics

Sample text

Since surely the person's soul, which is God's property, has already been withdrawn by God from this person, as upon removal of the machine he will immediately die. )9 In comparison with contemporary practice and expectations, this surely implies far too much. 20 Ha -Levi explicitly condones sustaining a patient in "artificial" life as a temporary measure, with a view to the return of "natural" life, that is, the capability for living without life-supporting accessories. 21 But if complete recovery is indeed never expected, Ha-Levi's logic seems to prohibit sustaining a person in artificial life.

A truly Maimonidean position here would call for incorporating possibilities of human intervention within the scope of God's will. If the Jews could successfully revolt, then the choice between submission and martyrdom would not exhaust their religiously valid options. 26 If, however, a revolt is deemed futile, then a pragmatic accommodation to the Roman decrees might be the proper form of human reaction to that historical situation. The heart of the story tells of R. Hanina's martyrdom. It is here that Waldenberg, like several other Halakhic writers, finds a paradigm for the predicament of the suffering, terminal patient.

Said [R. Yose]: "I speak to you words of reason, and you reply, 'From Heaven they will have mercy'! " ... Soon afterward, R. Yose ben Kisma passed away. All the Roman notables came to his funeral, and made a great eulogy. On their way back, they saw R. Hanina ben Teradion sitting engaged in Torah [study], [having] called a public assembly with a Torah scroll held in his bosom. They brought him in and wrapped him in the Torah scroll, surrounded him with bundles of vine shoots, and set them on fire.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.99 of 5 – based on 39 votes
Posted In CategoriesJewish